Paper vs Tablet: Why it matters for GTD

There is something fundamentally limiting about the typed English language that dances across the screens of the world. I have all the technology that would make going paperless as easy as possible, yet sitting in front of me is still a book full of scrawlings.

Paper gives me more working space. It can be used for doodling, or just jotting down random ideas, but I always find myself referring back to it. I don’t have to try and rephrase what I’m thinking in to words, I can just express it exactly as I imagine it. It is this kind of freedom that allows me to produce work of a higher standard. I almost use paper as a draft, something that I will later refine into structured and typed thoughts. So where does GTD come into this?

A computerized GTD system is great for organizing things, but it doesn’t implicitly allow for the incubation of ideas on a short term scale. You may argue that GTD is all about focusing your energies: but by immediately focusing yourself, you rule out possibilities that may only arise from being exposed to two different concepts at once. My paper notebook becomes my brainstorming book: it is with me throughout the day, and it catches all of those small little things that come to mind that don’t even justify a place in my inbox. The paper notebook offers something that computerized systems just haven’t been able to match: flexibility.

I use and love my Tablet PC, yet I find myself preferring pen and paper. For some reason paper just feels better – its much more accurate and precise. It also gives more tactile feedback adding greatly to the experience. Although similar in use, paper is a more flexible medium just due to those factors alone, which makes using it quick and painless. I don’t have to turn my laptop on, then swivel it round into tablet mode, and then write. Its simply flick to a page and begin.

While I am a huge advocate of computing in general, until tablets offer the same experience as pen and paper, computerized GTD systems will not be complete without at least one paper inbox.

About this entry